Return Policy

Revised May 9, 2024

We are very grateful for your purchase and hope you are pleased with your new comics and/or coffee stuffs. However, if you are not completely satisfied with your purchase for any reason, you may return it to us for a full refund or store credit. Please see below for more information on our return policy.

Orders Lost or Damaged in Shipping

If your order arrived damaged, please let us know ASAP by contacting us via our online contact form. We’ll do our best to make things right for you, whether that means crediting your account, refunding your money, or reshipping your order as needed. If the packaging is still intact, please keep it, take photos and send them to, as we may need them to file an insurance claim. You have seven business days from the date of receipt to report any damaged goods.


To begin the return process, you can contact and send pictures of damaged products to, or via our online contact form to let us know. Items sent back to us without first requesting a return will not be accepted. All returns must be postmarked within thirty (30) days of the purchase date. All returned items must be in new and unused condition, with all original tags and labels attached along with order receipt.

Return Process

To return an item, place the item securely in its original packaging and include your proof of purchase, then mail your return to the following address:

Blackwater Market Comics & Coffee
Attn: Returns
PO Box 3628
Mansfield, Ohio 44907
United States

Please note, you will be responsible for all return shipping charges. We strongly recommend that you use a trackable method to mail your return.


After receiving your return and inspecting the condition of your item, we will process your return. Please allow at least fourteen (14) days from the receipt of your item to process your return. Refunds may take 1-2 billing cycles to appear on your credit card statement, depending on your credit card company. We will notify you by email when your return has been processed. A copy of your order receipt must be included with your return, or it will not be accepted.


The following items cannot be returned or exchanged:

  • coffee
  • tea
  • gift cards
  • downloadable products
  • custom products
  • special orders
  • personalized items
  • sale items

For defective or damaged products, please contact us at the contact details below to arrange a refund or exchange. Please note, sale items are final and cannot be returned.


If you have any questions concerning our return policy, please email us at, or via our online contact form or by post to:

Blackwater Market Comics & Coffee
Attn: Returns
PO Box 3628
Mansfield, Ohio 44907
United States